It's way too early to grade anything involved in the draft. In fact, I've gone from one of the guys who'd grade a draft the day after to someone who now understands that a draft class can't be gauged until after two or three years. Take for example the now infamous Reggie Bush draft. The Texans were raked over the coals for selecting Mario Williams over Bush and Vince Young, mainly at the behest of ESPN. I bought that hype and thought that you needed to take a gamebreaker like Bush. I wasn't so high on Young, but then again, with the exception of Peyton Manning, Carson Palmer and Byron Leftwich (lol), I hated every single 1st round QB that's been taken in the last 15 years on draft day. (thank God I was wrong about McNabb!) Well, it turns out that the Texans were right, now that VY is on a fast track out of the league with mental problems and Reggie Bush is quickly becoming the second coming of Eric Metcalf.
That being said, draft analysis isn't all bunk, but I think a lot of what can be gauged has to do with teams addressing needs. So let's start:
- Of course, we begin with the home team, the Eagles. When they picked Jeremy Maclin, my initial thought was, "Fuck, another first round receiver? Why couldn't they have just pulled the trigger on Boldin?" I would much rather have had Brandon Pettigrew. However, when they pulled LeSean McCoy, who was THE RB that I wanted in this draft (well actually, Moreno was the one I wanted but we never had a chance at him... more on that later), and then got a TE with upside that fell because of an injury in the later rounds, I was happy. I thought we did good.
- The Denver Broncos spent millions of free agent money signing RBs... Correll Buckhalter, JJ Arrington, LaMont Jordan... and defensively they were leakier than a water-tank riddled with bullet holes, and they pick Knowshown Moreno? WTF? Does this new regime have a clue as to what they're doing? First this shit McDaniels comes in and chases out their budding franchise QB, getting Neckbeard Orton in return. Now, instead of trading up to get Mark Sanchez or down to get Josh Freeman, or staying put and drafting, oh, I don't know, Brian Orakpo, Malcolm Jenkins, Brian Cushing or Robert Ayers? Fuck them. I hope they go 0-16 this year for the undeservedly arrogant way they've been acting this offseason. It's such a shame that Dawk went there to play for that little shit rather than go to a quality organization. Fuck Belichick and fuck all his disciples.
- The other AFC West making the WTF? moves were the Raiders. Okay, so maybe Darrius Heyward-Bey might end up being a better pro than Michael Crabtree. I mean, I don't know, it's all a crapshoot like I said above. That being said, more people coveted Crabtree than Heyward-Bey, and if the Raiders really wanted him, they could have traded out of the pick and got a few more picks to stockpile their still struggling team. Then, there was the second round pick of the guy that at least one other team had rated as a free agent pickup post-draft. Of course, this was according to Helmet Hair, so take it with a grain of salt. The Bears actually also wanted to pick this kid from Ohio as well, so maybe they had less pompous scouts look at him. Looking back it, I'd rather not trust Mel Kiper to say some kid didn't deserve to be drafted in the second round. But still... Heyward-Bey over Crabtree at that spot? You've gotta trade.
- I'm so glad the Jets took Mark Sanchez at that spot, because I don't think I could have taken another draft day of ESPN manufacturing a story about how emo the dropping-QB was feeling after being passed up by so many teams.
- Speaking of the QBs... it's still sad how teams overrate QBs and take them where they do, but Steve Young capsulized it best by saying "It's a quarterback league." That's the mentality. Trent Dilfer leading the '00 Ravens to a title was an anomaly. Still, much like every year, I didn't like any of the first round QBs to become grade-A signal callers in this league. I do like Stafford, but he's going into a shit situation with high expectations of being not only the first pick overall, but to be the first Lions All-Pro QB in almost 40 years. Sanchez is going into a great situation, but he really has the weakest resume of the three. Josh Freeman, I think, is going into the best situation given the overall makeup of the conference. However, I still don't like Big 12 QBs who tend to have inflated stats in a conference that isn't exactly known for its defense. But unlike Kiper, I don't think Sanchez is the least likely to bust. I think all three of them are equal chance.
- Some picks I liked: Hakeem Nicks to the Giants (he should be able to replace Plax eventually, same body type, will definitely get passes from Eli Manning)
Eugene Monroe to the Jags (I know they need some skill players, but you gotta build the line first. Monroe could be better than either of the Smiths taken before him)
James Laurinitis to the Rams (shit, how can you go wrong with the son of Road Warrior Animal playing Mike Linebacker?)
Everette Brown to the Panthers (first round talent late.. he won't replace Julius Peppers, but I don't think he'll be a drastic downgrade either)
Shonn Green to the Jets (how he lasted to the third round is beyond me)
- Some picks I didn't like: Percy Harvin to the Vikings (too much athlete and not enough receiver... I have a feeling he's another Reggie Bush type, but hey, at least he wasn't taken 2nd overall)
Beanie Wells to the Cards (an ACL tear waiting to happen)
That's it. Feel free to comment!